Wrestling All-Americans
Twelve different Princeton wrestlers have combined to earn 27 All-America honors for Princeton. Bradley Glass '53 was Princeton's lone NCAA champion (1951, unlimited) until 2023, when Patrick Glory '23 (125) joined him, and Emil Deliere '72, John Sefter '78, John Orr '85, Greg Parker '03 and Quincy Monday '23 are all former finalists. Over the last six NCAA Championship tournaments held in which Princeton competed (2016-19, 22-23), Princeton has placed five wrestlers on the NCAA podium a total of 10 times, including Brett Harner (2016, 184, New York City), Matthew Kolodzik (2017, 141, St. Louis; 2018, 149, Cleveland; 2019, 149, Pittsburgh), Patrick Glory (2019, 125, Pittsburgh; 2022, 125, Detroit; 2023, 125, Tulsa), Patrick Brucki (2019, 197, Pittsburgh) and Quincy Monday (2022, 157, Detroit; 2023, 165, Tulsa).
Below is a chart of Princeton's All-America wrestlers.
| Name | Year | Weight | Place | Location |
| Warren Taylor '43 | 1942 | 136 | 4th | Michigan State |
| Bradley Glass '53 | 1951 | Unlimited | Champion | Lehigh |
| Bradley Glass '53 | 1952 | 191 | 3rd | Colorado State |
| Emil Deliere '72 | 1970 | 190 | 6th | Northwestern |
| Emil Deliere '72 | 1972 | 190 | 2nd | Maryland |
| John Sefter '78 | 1977 | Unlimited | 6th | Oklahoma |
| John Sefter '78 | 1978 | Unlimited | 2nd | Maryland |
| Henry Milligan '81 | 1981 | 190 | 6th | Princeton |
| John Orr '85 | 1984 | 142 | 2nd | Meadowlands |
| Dave Crisanti '86 | 1985 | 118 | 8th | Oklahoma City |
| John Orr '85 | 1985 | 142 | 2nd | Oklahoma City |
| Greg Parker '03 | 2002 | 174 | 2nd | Albany |
| Greg Parker '03 | 2003 | 184 | 8th | Kansas City |
| Brett Harner '17 | 2016 | 197 | 8th | New York City |
| Matthew Kolodzik '20 | 2017 | 141 | 7th | St. Louis |
| Matthew Kolodzik '20 | 2018 | 149 | 3rd | Cleveland |
| Matthew Kolodzik '20 | 2019 | 149 | 5th | Pittsburgh |
| Patrick Glory '22 | 2019 | 125 | 6th | Pittsburgh |
| Patrick Brucki '21 | 2019 | 197 | 4th | Pittsburgh |
| Patrick Glory '22 | 2020 | 125 | First Team* | |
| Matthew Kolodzik '20 | 2020 | 149 | First Team* | |
| Quincy Monday '22 | 2020 | 157 | First Team* | |
| Patrick Brucki '21 | 2020 | 197 | First Team* | |
| Patrick Glory '23 | 2022 | 125 | 2nd | Detroit |
| Quincy Monday '23 | 2022 | 157 | 2nd | Detroit |
| Patrick Glory '23 | 2023 | 125 | 1st | Tulsa |
| Quincy Monday '23 | 2023 | 165 | 3rd | Tulsa |