First-Team All-Ivy League
| 1957 | |
| Doug Levick | D |
| Alvin Krongard | M |
| Gordon Smith | A |
| 1958 | |
| Doug Levick | D |
| Dave Callard | D |
| John Heyd | M |
| Gordon Smith | A |
| 1959 | |
| Jack Horton | D |
| Dave Callard | D |
| John Heyd | M |
| 1960 | |
| Howard Krongard | G |
| Jack Horton | D |
| Phillip Allen | M |
| Bob Milling | A |
| 1961 | |
| Howard Krongard | G |
| Phillip Allen | M |
| Perry Hall | M |
| Bill Miles | A |
| 1962 | |
| Tim Callard | D |
| Art Hyland | D |
| Phillip Allen | M |
| 1963 | |
| Webb Harrison | G |
| Tim Callard | D |
| Bob Kent | A |
| 1964 | |
| Bob Moore | M |
| 1965 | |
| Tino O’Brien | A |
| 1966 | |
| John Baker | D |
| Marty Eichelberger | M |
| 1967 | |
| John Baker | D |
| Al Keidel | M |
| Jim Karanik | A |
| 1968 | |
| Al Keidel | M |
| Jim Karanik | A |
| 1970 | |
| Mike Manzo | D |
| Pete Lips | M |
| 1973 | |
| Bill Chaires | A |
| 1974 | |
| Bill Chaires | A |
| 1975 | |
| Kevin Gray | G |
| Dave Tickner | A |
| 1976 | |
| Kevin Lonnie | D |
| Dave Tickner | A |
| 1977 | |
| Dave Tickner | M |
| Wick Sollers | A |
| 1978 | |
| Tom Leyden | M |
| Dave Heubeck | A |
| 1981 | |
| Peter Cordrey | G |
| Steve Delligatti | M |
| Paul Hollis | A |
| 1982 | |
| Peter Cordrey | G |
| Steve Delligatti | M |
| 1983 | |
| Bob Flippin | M |
| Gerry Ronon | A |
| 1984 | |
| David Chang | M |
| Rob Hawley | M |
| 1987 | |
| Rob Palumbo | A |
| 1988 | |
| Rob Palumbo | A |
| 1990 | |
| John Kenny | M |
| 1991 | |
| Scott Bacigalupo | G |
| David Morrow | D |
| Andy Moe | M |
| Justin Tortolani | A |
| 1992 | |
| Scott Bacigalupo | G |
| Mike Mariano | D |
| David Morrow | D |
| Andy Moe | M |
| Justin Tortolani | A |
| Kevin Lowe | A |
| 1993 | |
| Scott Bacigalupo | G |
| David Morrow | D |
| Scott Reinhardt | M |
| Kevin Lowe | A |
| Taylor Simmers | A |
| 1994 | |
| Scott Conklin | A |
| Todd Higgins | D |
| Kevin Lowe | A |
| Scott Reinhardt | M |
| 1995 | |
| Scott Conklin | A |
| Todd Higgins | D |
| Jeff MacBean | M |
| 1996 | |
| Todd Eichelberger | M |
| Jon Hess | A |
| Jesse Hubbard | A |
| Rob Neff | DM |
| Becket Wolf | D |
| 1997 | |
| Christian Cook | D |
| Jon Hess | A |
| Jesse Hubbard | A |
| K. Lunkenheimer | D |
| Chris Massey | A |
| Lorne Smith | M |
| Becket Wolf | D |
| 1998 | |
| Christian Cook | D |
| Jesse Hubbard | A |
| K. Lunkenheimer | D |
| Chris Massey | A |
| Josh Sims | M |
| 1999 | |
| John Harrington | D |
| B.J. Prager | A |
| Josh Sims | M |
| Lorne Smith | M |
| 2000 | |
| Ryan Mollett | D |
| B.J. Prager | A |
| Josh Sims | M |
| 2001 | |
| Sean Hartofilis | A |
| Ryan Mollett | D |
| Matt Striebel | M |
| Trevor Tierney | G |
| Rob Torti | M |
| 2002 | |
| Ryan Boyle | A |
| Damien Davis | D |
| Brad Dumont | M |
| B.J. Prager | A |
| 2003 | |
| Ryan Boyle | A |
| Damien Davis | D |
| Brad Dumont | M |
| Sean Hartofilis | A |
| 2004 | |
| Oliver Barry | D |
| Ryan Boyle | A |
| Ricky Schultz | D |
| 2005 | |
| Oliver Barry | D |
| 2006 | |
| Dan Cocoziello | D |
| 2007 | |
| Zachary Jungers | D |
| Mark Kovler | M |
| Scott Sowanick | M |
| Peter Trombino | A |
| 2008 | |
| Dan Cocoziello | D |
| 2009 | |
| Mark Kovler | M |
| Jack McBride | A |
| Chad Wiedmaier | D |
| 2010 | |
| Mike Chanenchuk | M |
| Tyler Fiorito | G |
| Jack McBride | A |
| Chad Wiedmaier | D |
| 2011 | |
| Tyler Fiorito | G |
| Tom Schreiber | M |
| Chad Wiedmaier | D |
| 2012 | |
| Tyler Fiorito | G |
| Jeff Froccaro | A |
| Tom Schreiber | M |
| Chad Wiedmaier | D |
| 2013 | |
| Mike MacDonald | A |
| Tom Schreiber | M |
| 2014 | |
| Tom Schreiber | M |
| 2015 | |
| Mike MacDonald | A |
| Kip Orban | M |
| 2016 | |
| Zach Currier | M |
| 2017 | |
| Tyler Blaisdell | G |
| Zach Currier | M |
| Bear Goldstein | D |
| Michael Sowers | A |
| 2018 | |
| Austin Sims | M |
| Michael Sowers | A |
| 2019 | |
| George Baughan | D |
| Michael Sowers | A |
| 2020, 2021 - no All-Ivy League due to Covid 19 | |
| 2022 | |
| George Baughan | D |
| Chris Brown | A |
| 2023 | |
| Coulter Mackesy | A |
| Alexander Vardaro | M |
| 2024 | |
| Colin Mulshine | D |
| Marquez White | SSDM |
| 2025 | |
| Ryan Croddick | G |
| Coutler Mackesy | A |
| Cooper Mueller | SSDM |
| Colin Mulshine | D |
| Tucker Wade | M |