All-America
CROSS COUNTRY
| Jack Fonss | 1981 |
| Josh LeMay | 1988 |
| Paul Morrison | 1999 |
| Mike Spence | 1999 |
| Frank Macreery | 2005 |
| David Nightingale | 2006 |
| Michael Maag | 2007 |
| Donn Cabral | 2010, 11 |
| Brian Leung | 2010 |
| Nicholas Bendtsen | 2023 |
TRACK & FIELD
| Indoor All-America | ||||
| Dave Pellagrini | Weight | 1st | 1980 | |
| August Wolf | Shot Put | n/a | 1982 | |
| August Wolf | Shot Put | 2nd | 1983 | |
| Sean Purcell | Shot Put | n/a | 1986 | |
| Bill Burke | Mile | n/a | 1990 | |
| Bill Burke | Mile | 5th | 3:59.70 | 1991 |
| Jay Richards | High Jump | 4th | 2.23 (7-3.25) | 1992 |
| Alex Hastings, | ||||
| Andy Collins, | ||||
| Chris Lear, | ||||
| Scott Anderson | DMR | 4th | 9:42.51 | 1994 |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | Long Jump | 6th | 7.61 (24-11.75) | 1996 |
| Tora Harris | High Jump | 1st | 2.26 (7-5.00) | 2002 |
| David Nightingale | Mile | 8th | 4:03.13 | 2007 |
| Justin Frick | High Jump | 9th | 2.09 (6-10.25) | 2009 |
| Alex Pessala | Weight | 10th | 20.32 (66-8) | 2009 |
| First Team | ||||
| Donn Cabral | 5,00 | 8th | 13:53.14 | 2012 |
| Peter Callahan | Mile | 6th | 4:02.66 | 2012 |
| Peter Callahan | DMR | 1st | 9:33.01 | 2013 |
| Russell Dinkins | DMR | 1st | 9:33.01 | 2013 |
| Austin Hollimon | DMR | 1st | 9:33.01 | 2013 |
| Michael Williams | DMR | 1st | 9:33.01 | 2013 |
| Sondre Guttormsen | Pole Vault | 1st | 5.75 | 2022 |
| Simen Guttormsen | Pole Vault | 4th | 5.60 | 2022 |
| Andrei Iosivas | Heptathlon | 4th | 6069 | 2022 |
| Harrison Witt | DMR | 4th | 9:26.01 | 2022 |
| Michael Phillipy | DMR | 4th | 9:26.01 | 2022 |
| Sam Rodman | DMR | 4th | 9:26.01 | 2022 |
| Sam Ellis | DMR | 4th | 9:26.01 | 2022 |
| C.J. Licata | Shot Put | 8th | 19.75 | 2022 |
| Sondre Guttormsen | Pole Vault | 1st | 6.00m | 2023 |
| Second Team | ||||
| Damon McLean | Triple Jump | 14th | 15.44 (50-8) | 2013 |
| Michael Williams | Mile | 14th | 4:13.07 | 2014 |
| Adam Kelly | Weight Throw | 10th | 21.13 (69-4) | 2017 |
| Sam Rodman | 800m (prelim) | 9th | 1:49.94 | 2023 |
| Greg Foster | Long Jump | 15th | 7.51m | 2023 |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Adam Kelly | Weight Throw | 15th | foul | 2018 |
| Outdoor All-America | ||||
| Kelsey Harvey | 220 Yards | n/a | 1943 | |
| Taylor F. Morgan | Broad Jump | n/a | 1952, 1953 | |
| Tom Meyer | Javelin | 7th | 75.92 | 1981 |
| August Wolf | Shot Put | 6th | 19.44 (63-9.50) | 1983 |
| Peter Hunt | Decathlon | 9th | 7,232 pts | 1988 |
| Charles Forlidas | High Jump | 7th | 2.21 | 1989 |
| Joe LeMay | 10,000 | 8th | 30:05.19 | 1989 |
| Al Dyer | Long Jump | 4th | 7.87 (25-9.75) | 1990 |
| Bill Burke | 1,500 | 6th | 3:40.78 | 1991 |
| Jay Richards | High Jump | 6th | 2.21 (7-3) | 1992 |
| Tora Harris | High Jump | 7th | 2.19 (7-2) | 1998 |
| Tora Harris | High Jump | 5th | 2.24 | 1999 |
| Tora Harris | High Jump | 4th | 2.24 | 2001 |
| Tora Harris | High Jump | 1st | 2.25 (7-4.50) | 2002 |
| Frank Macreery | 10,000 | 10th | 29:21.70 | 2006 |
| David Nightingale | 5,000 | 8th | 13:55.15 | 2007 |
| Michael Maag | 5,000 | 10th | 14:14.67 | 2009 |
| Donn Cabral | 5,000 | 6th | 13:53.33 | 2010 |
| Donn Cabral | Steeple | 2nd | 8:38.90 | 2010 |
| First Team | ||||
| Donn Cabral | 5,000 | 8th | 13:40.62 | 2011 |
| Donn Cabral | Steeple | 2nd | 8:32.14 | 2011 |
| Donn Cabral | Steeple | 1st | 8:35.44 | 2012 |
| Damon McLean | Triple | 8th | 16.03 (52-7.25) | 2012 |
| Michael Franklin | 10,000 | 5th | 29:42.34 | 2013 |
| Stephen Soerens | Decathlon | 6th | 7,669 | 2015 |
| Adam Braggg | Pole Vault | 7th | 5.30 (17-4.50) | 2016 |
| Sondre Guttormsen | Pole Vault | 1st | 5.75 | 2022 |
| Simen Guttormsen | Pole Vault | 4th | 5.65 | 2022 |
| Sam Ellis | 1,500 | 3rd | 3:45.82 | 2022 |
| Ed Trippas | Steeple | 5th | 8:20.29 | 2022 |
| Sam Rodman | 800 | 7th | 1:46.96 | 2022 |
| Second Team | ||||
| Craig Pearce | Hammer | 16th | 61.82 (202-10) | 2011 |
| David Slovenski | Pole Vault | 12th | 5.25 (17.275) | 2011 |
| Mark Amirault | 5,000 | 12th | 13:54.51 | 2011 |
| Mike Eddy | 4x400 | 12th | 3:06.94 | 2011 |
| Tom Hopkins | 4x400 | 12th | 3:06.94 | 2011 |
| Austin Hollimon | 4x400 | 12th | 3:06.94 | 2011 |
| Russell Dinkins | 4x400 | 12th | 3:06.94 | 2011 |
| 800 | 16th | 1:50.70 | 2013 | |
| Brian Leung | 10,000 | 16th | 29:58.45 | 2012 |
| Joe Stilin | 5,000 | 14th | 14:03.76 | 2012 |
| Trevor Van Ackeren | 1500 | 14th | 3:42.83 | 2012 |
| Chris Bendtsen | 10,000 | 9th | 29:14.86 | 2014 |
| Adam Bragg | Pole Vault | 12th | 5.10 | 2014 |
| Damon McLean | Triple Jump | 12th | 15.85 | 2014 |
| Sam Pons | 10,000 | 9th | 29:17.54 | 2015 |
| Adam Kelly | Hammer | 9th | 70.27 | 2018 |
| William Paulson | 1500 | 13th | 3:48.09 | 2018 |
| Conor Lundy | 5,000 | 15th | 14:04.08 | 2018 |
| Joey Daniels | 110m Hurdles | 12th | 13.07 | 2019 |
| C.J. Licata | Shot Put | 13th | 19.31 | 2022 |
| Robbie Otal | Discus | 16th | 55.92 | |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Russell Dinkins | 800 | 19th | 1:48.26 | 2011 |
| 4x400 | 22nd | 3:09.84 | 2013 | |
| Tom Hopkins | 4x400 | 22nd | 3:09.84 | 2013 |
| Daniel McCord | 4x400 | 22nd | 3:09.84 | 2013 |
| Austin Hollimon | 4x400 | 22nd | 3:09.84 | 2013 |
| 400 Hurdles | 24th | 54.82 | 2013 | |
| Chris Bendtsen | 10,000 | 22nd | 31:06.83 | 2013 |
| Eddie Owens | Steeplechase | 23rd | 9:05.28 | 2014 |
| Adam Kelly | Hammer Throw | 14th | 65.82 (215-11) | 2016 |
| August Kiles | Pole Vault | t-22nd | NH | 2017 |
| William Paulson | 1500 | 24th | DNF | 2017 |
| Ed Trippas | Steeplechase | 23rd | 9:29.44 | 2019 |
| Jeffrey Hollis | High Jump | 19th | 2.10 | 2022 |
| Michael Phillippy | 400 | 21st | 46.37 | 2022 |
| Simang'aliso Ndhlovu | 4x100 | 23rd | 39.38 | 2022 |
| Greg Sholars | 4x100 | 23rd | 39.38 | 2022 |
| Daniel Duncan | 4x100 | 23rd | 39.38 | 2022 |
| Kaden Reynolds | 4x100 | 23rd | 39.38 | 2022 |
| Ladislav Töpfer | 4x400 | 23rd | 3:09.26 | |
| William Doyle | 4x400 | 23rd | 3:09.26 | |
| Andersen Dimon | 4x400 | 23rd | 3:09.26 | |
| Michael Phillippy | 4x400 | 23rd | 3:09.26 | |
1942-1962: Top 3
1963-1972: Top 4
1973-1981: unknown
1982-1984: Top 12 1985?-2005: Top 8, to include top 8 Americans
2006-2010: Top 8, to include top 8 Americans*
2011-present: Top 8 First Team, 9-16 Second Team, rest of finalists HM*