Alphabetical All-Ivy League
| Dayo Abeeb | First-Team Outdoor | Triple Jump | 2019 |
| Dayo Abeeb | Second-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 2020 |
| George Abyad | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2011 |
| George Abyad | Second-Team Outdoor | Discus | 2008, 11 |
| Nse Akang | Second-Team Indoor | 400 | 1984* |
| Nse Akang | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1984 |
| Tumi Akinlawon | Second-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 2015 |
| Tumi Akinlawon | First-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 2015 |
| Carrington Akosa | First-Team Indoor | 200 | 2015, 2016 |
| Carrington Akosa | First-Team Indoor | 60 | 2017, 2018 |
| Carrington Akosa | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2016 |
| Carrington Akosa | First-Team Outdoor | 100 | 2018 |
| Carrington Akosa | Second-Team Indoor | 60 | 2015, 2016 |
| Carrington Akosa | Second-Team Indoor | 200 | 2018 |
| Carrington Akosa | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2015 |
| Carrington Akosa | Second-Team Outdoor | 100 | 2016 |
| Mark Amirault | First-Team Indoor | Mile | 2011 |
| Mark Amirault | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2011 |
| Mark Amirault | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2010 |
| Mark Amirault | First-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2010, 11 |
| Mark Amirault | First-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 2011 |
| Mark Amirault | Second-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 2010 |
| Stefan Amokwandoh | Second-Team Indoor | Triple | 2017 |
| Stefan Amokwandoh | Second-Team Outdoor | Triple | 2018, 2019 |
| Jim Anderson | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1984, 86 |
| Jim Anderson | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1984, 86 |
| Jim Anderson | Second-Team Outdoor | 200 | 1983* |
| Jim Anderson | Second-Team Outdoor | 100 | 1986 |
| Scott Anderson | First-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 1993* |
| Scott Anderson | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1994 |
| Scott Anderson | First-Team Indoor | Mile | 1995 |
| Scott Anderson | Second-Team Indoor | Mile | 1996 |
| Scott Anderson | Second-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 1996 |
| Scott Anderson | First-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 1995, 96 |
| Scott Anderson | Second-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 1993, 94 |
| Scott Anderson | Second-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 1996 |
| Alejandro Arroyo Yamin | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2012 |
| Peter Arduino | All-Ivy Outdoor | 400 Hurdles | 1980 |
| Peter Arduino | First-Team Outdoor | 400 Hurdles | 1981, 82, 83 |
| Peter Arduino | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1983 |
| Franklin Aririguzoh | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2017 |
| Franklin Aririguzoh | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2016 |
| Tensai Asfaw | First-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 2001 |
| Tensai Asfaw | First-Team Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 2001 |
| Tensai Asfaw | Second-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 2000* |
| Cam Atkinson | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2000 |
| Cam Atkinson | First-Team Outdoor | 200 | 2003 |
| Cam Atkinson | Second-Team Outdoor | 100 | 2000 |
| Cam Atkinson | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2001 |
| Chandler Ault | Second-Team Outdoor | Javelin | 2022 |
| Douglas Austin | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1986 |
| Ibrahim Ayorinde | First Team Indoor | 200 | 2022 |
| Ibrahim Ayorinde | Second Team Indoor | 200 | 2023 |
| Ibrahim Ayorinde | Second Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2023 |
| Reuben Bailey | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1982 |
| Michael Baird | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2003 |
| George Baldock | Second-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 1996 |
| George Baldock | First-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1996 |
| Chris Banks | First-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 1998, 99, 2000 |
| Chris Banks | Second-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2000 |
| Dwayne Banton | First-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 2005 |
| Dwayne Banton | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2004 |
| Dwayne Banton | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 2005 |
| Dwayne Banton | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 2002 |
| Carl Barisich | All-Ivy Indoor | Shot Put | 1973 |
| Carl Barisich | All-Ivy Outdoor | Shot Put | 1971 |
| Solomon Barnett | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2004 |
| Antonio Barroco | Second-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 1998* |
| Reuben Bayley | First-Team Indoor | 800 | 1985 |
| Reuben Baylay | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1983, 84, 86 |
| Mike Becker | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1980 |
| Jonathan Bell | First-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 2003 |
| Jonathan Bell | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2003 |
| Jonathan Bell | Second-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2003 |
| Chris Bendtsen | Second-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 2012, 13 |
| Chris Bendtsen | Second-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 2013 |
| Chris Bendtsen | First-Team Outdoor | 10k | 2014 |
| Chris Bendtsen | Second-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 2013 |
| Nick Bendtsen | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2023 |
| Tyler Bengtson | Second-Team Indoor | Heptathlon | 2004 |
| Tyler Bengtson | Second-Team Outdoor | Decathlon | 2004 |
| William Bertrand | Second-Team Outdoor | 10k | 2017 |
| Johan Bettum | Second-Team Indoor | 800 | 1983 |
| Remo Biagioni | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 1981* |
| Josh Billington | First-Team Outdor | 4x100 | 2016 |
| Xavier Bledsoe | First-Team Indoor | High Jump | 2016, 2017 |
| Xavier Bledsoe | Second-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 2016, 2017 |
| Manny Bonilla | First-Team Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 1994 |
| Adam Bragg | First-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2014 |
| Adam Bragg | First-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2015, 2016 |
| Adam Bragg | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2012 |
| Luke Brahm | Second-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 2015, 2016 |
| Luke Brahm | Second-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 4x800 |
| Luke Brahm | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2016 |
| Tor Brostrom | All-Ivy Indoor | Triple Jump | 1978 |
| Tor Brostrom | First-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 1980 |
| Benson Brown | All-Ivy Outdoor | 440yd Hurdles | 1971 |
| Colin Brown | First-Team Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 2001 |
| Christian Brown | Second-Team Indoor | 60m Hurdles | 2019 |
| Christian Brown | Second-Team Indoor | 60m Hurdles | 2020 |
| Ken Bruce | Second-Team Indoor | 400 | 1981* |
| Ken Bruce | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1983 |
| Bill Burke | First-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 1991 |
| Bill Burke | First-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 1991 |
| Bill Burke | First-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 1991 |
| Matthew Butler | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1998 |
| Will Byrd | Second-Team Indoor | Heptathlon | 2008 |
| Will Byrd | Second-Team Outdoor | Decathlon | 2005, 06 |
| Will Byrd | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2008 |
| John Cabell | All-Ivy Indoor | 2 Mile | 1975*, 76*, 77 |
| John Cabell | All-Ivy Outdoor | 10,000 | 1976 |
| Donn Cabral | First-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 2011 |
| Donn Cabral | First-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 2011, 12 |
| Donn Cabral | Second-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 2010 |
| Donn Cabral | Second-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 2010 |
| Donn Cabral | First-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 2010, 11, 12 |
| Donn Cabral | First-Team Outdoor | Steeplechase | 2010, 11, 12 |
| Greg Caldwell | Second-Team Indoor | 60 Hurdles | 2016 |
| Greg Caldwell | Second-Team Outdoor | 110 Hurdles | 2015 |
| Peter Callahan | First-Team Indoor | 800 | 2010, 12 |
| Peter Callahan | First-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 2011 |
| Peter Callahan | First-Team Indoor | Mile | 2013 |
| Peter Callahan | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2010 |
| Peter Callahan | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2013 |
| Peter Callahan | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2011 |
| Peter Callahan | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2012 |
| Peter Callahan | First-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 2013 |
| Peter Callahan | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2013 |
| Austin Carbone | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2018 |
| Austin Carbone | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2018 |
| Jeff Carbonella | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2007 |
| Jeff Carbonella | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2010 |
| Jeff Carbonella | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2008 |
| Sandy Cargile | All-Ivy Indoor | 60 Hurdles | 1974* |
| Sandy Cargile | All-Ivy Outdoor | 120yd Hurdles | 1973* |
| John Carson | Second-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 1998 |
| Dan Challener | All-Ivy Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 1978 |
| Dan Challener | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1981 |
| Dan Challener | Second-Team Indoor | 1,500 | 1981* |
| Dan Challener | All-Ivy Outdoor | 1,500 | 1980 |
| Dan Challener | Second-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 1981 |
| Ivan Charbonneau | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2011, 12 |
| Mitchel Charles | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2017, 2018 |
| Mitchel Charles | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2018 |
| Mitchel Charles | First-Team Outdoor | Discus | 2018 |
| Mitchel Charles | Second-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2016 |
| Mitchel Charles | Second-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2016, 2017 |
| Mitchel Charles | Second-Team Outdoor | Discus | 2017 |
| Kelton Chastulik | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2019 |
| Kelton Chastulik | Second-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2020 |
| Connor Chen | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2023 |
| Gordon Christie | First-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 1982 |
| Gordon Christie | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1984 |
| Gordon Christie | Second-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 1984 |
| Gordon Christie | Second-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 1983 |
| Gordon Christie | First-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 1984 |
| Gordon Christie | First-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 1982, 83 |
| David Cleaves | All-Ivy Indoor | High Jump | 1975* |
| Keefe Clemons | First-Team Indoor | 800 | 1986, 87, 88 |
| Keefe Clemons | First-Team Outdoor | 800 | 1987 |
| Keefe Clemons | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1986 |
| JC Colangelo | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2020 |
| Tristan Colangelo | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2004 |
| Tristan Colangelo | Second-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 2004 |
| Tristan Colangelo | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2002 |
| Tristan Colangelo | Second-Team Outdoor | Steeplechase | 2002, 03 |
| Jim Colling | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 1999 |
| Jim Colling | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 1997 |
| Jim Colling | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1995 |
| Jim Colling | First-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 1999 |
| Jim Colling | Second-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 1996 |
| Andy Collins | First-Team Indoor | 500 | 1996 |
| Andy Collins | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1996 |
| Andy Collins | Second-Team Indoor | 500 | 1995 |
| Andy Collins | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1995 |
| Andy Collins | First-Team Outdoor | 400 Hurdles | 1994, 95, 96 |
| Andy Collins | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1994 |
| Chris Cook | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2016 |
| Chris Cook | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2016, 2017 |
| Chris Cook | Second-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2015, 2017 |
| Chris Cook | Second-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2015 |
| Steven Cooper | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1995 |
| Peter Corsi | First-Team Indoor | Weight | 1986 |
| Barney Costello | Second-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 1982 |
| Thomas Courtney | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1986 |
| Rocky Craley | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2003 |
| Rocky Craley | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2004 |
| Rocky Craley | Second-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2003 |
| Robert Crotty | First-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 1993* |
| Nathan Crumpton | Second-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 2008 |
| Joey Daniels | First-Team Outdoor | 110 Hurdles | 2017, 2019 |
| Joey Daniels | First-Team Indoor | 60 Hurdles | 2018, 2019 |
| Joey Daniels | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2018 |
| Joey Daniels | Second-Team Outdoor | 110 Hurdles | 2018 |
| Joey Daniels | First-Team Outdoor | 60 hurdles | 2020 |
| Mike Davila | First-Team Outdoor | 800 | 1986 |
| Derek Davis | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 2006 |
| David Dean | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2002, 03 |
| Brandon Delley | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1999 |
| Brandon Delley | First-Team Outdoor | 400 Hurdles | 1999 |
| Brandon Delley | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1999 |
| Scott Denbo | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 1999, 00, 01 |
| Scott Denbo | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 1998, 99, 00, 01 |
| Myles Derieg | First-Team Outdoor | Javelin | 1992 |
| Andrew Diehl | Second-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 2019 |
| Andersen Dimon | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2022 |
| Andersen Dimon | Second-Team Indoor | 500 | 2022 |
| Andersen Dimon | Second-Team Indoor | 500 | 2023 |
| Andersen Dimon | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2023 |
| Russell Dinkins | First-Team Indoor | 500 | 2010, 12, 13 |
| Russell Dinkins | First-Team Indoor | 800 | 2011 |
| Russell Dinkins | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2010 |
| Russell Dinkins | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2011 |
| Russell Dinkins | First-Team Outdoor | 800 | 2013 |
| Russell Dinkins | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2013 |
| Russell Dinkins | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2010, 12 |
| Russell Dinkins | Second-Team Outdoor | 800 | 2011 |
| Justice Dixon | First-Team Indoor | 200 | 2020 |
| William Doyle | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2022 |
| William Doyle | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2023 |
| Daniel Duncan | First-Team Outdoor | 100 | 2022 |
| Daniel Duncan | First-Team Outdoor | 200 | 2022 |
| Daniel Duncan | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2022 |
| Daniel Duncan | Second-Team Indoor | 200 | 2022 |
| Daniel Duncan | First-Team Indoor | 60m | 2023 |
| Al Dyer | First-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 1989, 90 |
| Mike Eddy | First-Team Indoor | 500 | 2008, 09, 11 |
| Mike Eddy | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2010, 11 |
| Mike Eddy | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2009 |
| Mike Eddy | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2009, 11 |
| Mike Eddy | First-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2009, 10 |
| Mike Eddy | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2008, 11 |
| Mike Eddy | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2010 |
| William Egi | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2012 |
| Paul Elcock | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1998 |
| Sam Ellis | First-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 2020 |
| Sam Ellis | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2020 |
| Sam Ellis | First-Team Indoor | 800 | 2022 |
| Sam Ellis | First-Team Indoor | Mile | 2022 |
| Sam Ellis | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2022 |
| Chad Faulkner | Second-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2010 |
| Chad Faulkner | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2008 |
| Kenan Farmer | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2017 |
| Matt Farmer | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 1981* |
| Matt Farmer | Second-Team Outdoor | Steeplechase | 1983 |
| Tom Fink | All-Ivy Indoor | Triple Jump | 1976* |
| Tom Fink | All-Ivy Outdoor | Triple Jump | 1976 |
| Jack Fonss | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1981 |
| Jack Fonss | First-Team Indoor | 1,500 | 1982 |
| Jack Fonss | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1982 |
| Jack Fonss | Second-Team Indoor | 800 | 1981* |
| Jack Fonss | Second-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 1984 |
| Jack Fonss | Second-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 1984 |
| Charles Forlidas | First-Team Indoor | High Jump | 1989 |
| Charles Forlidas | First-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 1987, 88, 89 |
| Greg Foster | First-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 2023 |
| Greg Foster | Second-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 2023 |
| Bill Foucher | All-Ivy Indoor | Long Jump | 1971 |
| Bill Foucher | All-Ivy Outdoor | 120yd Hurdles | 1971 |
| Bill Foucher | All-Ivy Outdoor | Long Jump | 1971 |
| Ian Fox | First-Team Indoor | High Jump | 2010 |
| Ian Fox | Second-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 2010 |
| Stephan Francks | All-Ivy Outdoor | Javelin | 1974, 75 |
| Michael Franklin | First-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 2013 |
| Michael Franklin | First-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2013 |
| Michael Franklin | First-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 2013 |
| Josh Freeman | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2017 |
| Josh Freeman | First-Team Indoor | 400 | 2018 |
| Josh Freeman | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2018 |
| Josh Freeman | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2017 |
| Josh Freeman | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2018 |
| Justin Frick | First-Team Indoor | High Jump | 2008, 09 |
| Justin Frick | Second-Team Indoor | High Jump | 2010 |
| Justin Frick | First-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 2007, 10 |
| Justin Frick | Second-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 2008 |
| Kevin Gallagher | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2002 |
| Paul Gallup | Second-Team Indoor | Mile Relay | 2001 |
| Paul Gallup | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 1999 |
| Joey Gant | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2023 |
| Holland Gary | Second-Team Indoor | 55 | 1997 |
| Holland Gary | First-Team Indoor | 55 Hurdles | 1995 |
| Drew Geant | First-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 2005 |
| Kent George | First-Team Outdoor | Javelin | 1986, 90 |
| Matt Gonzalez | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2010 |
| Pierre Gourdon | All-Ivy Outdoor | 400 | 1976 |
| Jim Graves | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1995 |
| Mike Gray | First-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 1982 |
| Mike Gray | Second-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 1980, 83 |
| Mike Gray | First-Team Outdoor | Triple Jump | 1981, 82 |
| Mike Gray | Second-Team Outdoor | Triple Jump | 1983 |
| Doug Greenwood | All-Ivy Indoor | Weight | 1971, 72, 73 |
| Doug Greenwood | All-Ivy Outdoor | Hammer | 1972, 73 |
| Rob Grote | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2005, 08 |
| Witek Grzymala-Busse | First-Team Indoor | Weight | 1993, 95 |
| Witek Grzymala-Busse | Second-Team Indoor | Weight | 1994 |
| Witek Grzymala-Busse | Second-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 1994 |
| Sondre Guttormsen | First-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2022 |
| Sondre Guttormsen | First-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2022 |
| Sondre Guttormsen | First-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2023 |
| Simen Guttormsen | Second-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2020, 22 |
| Simen Guttormsen | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2022 |
| Gene Halton | All-Ivy Indoor | High Jump | 1971, 72 |
| Gene Halton | All-Ivy Outdoor | High Jump | 1971, 72 |
| Joel Harrington | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1995 |
| Joel Harrington | First-Team Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 1994 |
| Joel Harrington | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 1997 |
| Tora Harris | First-Team Indoor | High Jump | 1998, 99, 01, 02 |
| Tora Harris | First-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 1998, 99, 01, 02 |
| Al Hastings | First-Team Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 1994 |
| Al Hastings | Second-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 1994 |
| Al Hastings | First-Team Outdoor | 800 | 1994 |
| Al Hastings | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1994 |
| Tom Hayes | All-Ivy Indoor | Pole Vault | 1972 |
| Tom Hayes | All-Ivy Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1971, 72 |
| Charles Hedrick | All-Ivy Indoor | 1,000yd | 1976 |
| Charles Hedrick | All-Ivy Outdoor | 800 | 1976 |
| Charles Hedrick | All-Ivy Outdoor | 880yd | 1975 |
| Dan Heimerdinger | First-Team Outdoor | Steeplechase | 1981* |
| George Henschke | First-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 1982* |
| John Hill | First-Team Outdoor | 100 | 2014, 15 |
| John Hill | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2013, 14, 15 |
| Bob Hohf | All-Ivy Indoor | Pole Vault | 1971 |
| Austin Hollimon | First-Team Indoor | 400 | 2010, 11 |
| Austin Hollimon | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2010, 11, 13 |
| Austin Hollimon | First-Team Outdoor | 200 | 2009 |
| Austin Hollimon | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2009, 11, 13 |
| Austin Hollimon | First-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2011 |
| Austin Hollimon | First-Team Outdoor | 400 Hurdles | 2013 |
| Austin Hollimon | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2009 |
| Jeffrey Hollis | First-Team Indoor | High Jump | 2018, 20 |
| Jeffrey Hollis | Second-Team Indoor | High Jump | 2019 |
| Jeffrey Hollis | First-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 2019, 22 |
| Jeffrey Hollis | Second-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 2018 |
| Tom Hopkins | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2011, 13, 14 |
| Tom Hopkins | First-Team Indoor | 400 | 2012 |
| Tom Hopkins | First-Team Indoor | 500 | 2014 |
| Tom Hopkins | First-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 2014 |
| Tom Hopkins | Second-Team Indoor | 400 | 2013 |
| Tom Hopkins | First-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 2011, 13 |
| Tom Hopkins | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2011, 13 |
| Tom Hopkins | First-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2012, 2014 |
| Tom Hopkins | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2011, 12, 13, 14 |
| Tom Hopkins | Second-Team Outdoor | 200 | 2011, 12, 14 |
| Tom Hopkins | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 2012, 14 |
| Tom Hopkins | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2012, 14 |
| Tom Hopkins | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2013 |
| Rob Howell | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 1997 |
| Rob Howell | Second-Team Indoor | Mile | 1997 |
| Joe Hughes | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1996 |
| Joe Hughes | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 1997 |
| Rob Hulick | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2003 |
| Rob Hulick | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2004 |
| Rob Hulick | First-Team Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 2001 |
| Rob Hulick | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2002 |
| Derek Hynes | Second-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2011 |
| Derek Hynes | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2011 |
| Duane Hynes | First-Team Indoor | Heptathlon | 2008, 09 |
| Duane Hynes | Second-Team Indoor | Heptathlon | 2007 |
| Duane Hynes | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 2007 |
| Bob Igoe | Second-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 1984 |
| Bob Igoe | First-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 1984 |
| Bob Igoe | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 1982* |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | First-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 1995, 96 |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | First-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 1994, 95 |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | Second-Team Indoor | High Jump | 1996 |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | Second-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 1994 |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | Second-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 1993* |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | First-Team Outdoor | Triple Jump | 1993, 94, 95, 96 |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | First-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 1995 |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | First-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 1995 |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | Second-Team Outdoor | 100 | 1995* |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 1994, 96 |
| Ugwunna Ikpeowo | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1994 |
| Josh Ingalls | First-Team Indoor | 800 | 2016 |
| Josh Ingalls | First-Team Outdoor | 800 | 2018 |
| Josh Ingalls | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2016, 2017, 2018 |
| Andrei Iosivas | First-Team Indoor | Heptathlon | 2019, 20, 22 |
| Neil Jasey | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1996 |
| Neil Jasey | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1995 |
| Otis Jennings | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 1993* |
| Bill Jennings | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1984, 86 |
| Jon Jessup | First-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2000, 01 |
| Jon Jessup | First-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2000 |
| Jon Jessup | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1999* |
| Jabari Johnson | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2014, 2017 |
| Gwyn Jones | Second-Team Outdoor | Triple Jump | 1986* |
| Andy Kappel | All-Ivy Outdoor | 440yd Hurdles | 1971 |
| Andy Kappel | All-Ivy Outdoor | 4x440yd | 1972 |
| John Karakoulakis | Second-Team Indoor | Mile Relay | 2001 |
| John Karakoulakis | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2002 |
| Shafiq Kashmiri | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2007 |
| Phil Kastner | First-Team Indoor | Heptathlon | 2023 |
| Josh Kauke | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2003, 04 |
| Josh Kauke | Second-Team Indoor | 800 | 2003 |
| Josh Kauke | Second-Team Indoor | Mile Relay | 2001 |
| Josh Kauke | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2002 |
| Noah Kauppila | First-Team Indoor | 1000 | 2016 |
| Noah Kauppila | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2018 |
| Noah Kauppila | Second-Team Indoor | 1000 | 2017 |
| Noah Kauppila | Second-Team Indoor | Mile | 2018 |
| Noah Kauppila | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2017 |
| Noah Kauppila | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2016, 2018 |
| Jordan Kaplan | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2023 |
| Erin Kean | Second-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 1997* |
| Ricky Kearney | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2010, 11 |
| Ricky Kearney | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2009 |
| Ricky Kearney | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2011 |
| Ricky Kearney | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2010, 12 |
| Ricky Kearney | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2011 |
| Ian Keith | All-Ivy Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 1978 |
| Ian Keith | All-Ivy Indoor | 4x800 | 1977 |
| Ian Keith | All-Ivy Outdoor | 800 | 1977 |
| Adam Kelly | First-Team Indoor | Weight | 2018, 2019 |
| Adam Kelly | First-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 2018, 2019 |
| Adam Kelly | Second-Team Indoor | Weight | 2016, 2017 |
| Adam Kelly | Second-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 2016, 2017 |
| Hugh Kennedy | First-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 1999 |
| Hugh Kennedy | Second-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 1998 |
| Jeff Key | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 Hurdles | 2002, 04 |
| Jonathan Kieliszak | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2002, 03, 04 |
| Jonathan Kieliszak | First-Team Indoor | Mile | 2002, 04 |
| Jonathan Kieliszak | Second-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 2003 |
| Jonathan Kieliszak | First-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 2004 |
| Jonathan Kieliszak | Second-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 2003 |
| August Kiles | First-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2016, 2017, 2018 |
| August Kiles | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2017 |
| August Kiles | Second-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2015 |
| August Kiles | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2015, 2016 |
| Peter Kimball | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1997 |
| Peter Kimball | First-Team Indoor | 800 | 1998 |
| Peter Kimball | Second-Team Outdoor | 800 | 1998 |
| Alex Kolovyansky | First-Team Outdoor | Discus | 1995, 96 |
| Alex Kolovyansky | Second-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 1994, 96 |
| Jerry Kooymans | All-Ivy Outdoor | Steeplechase | 1977 |
| Jerry Kooymans | All-Ivy Outdoor | Steeplechase | 1975 |
| Mike Kopp | First-Team Indoor | 500 | 2004 |
| Mike Kopp | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2005 |
| Mike Kopp | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2004 |
| Mike Kopp | Second-Team Indoor | 500 | 2005 |
| Mike Kopp | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2004 |
| Mike Kopp | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2002 |
| Eli Krahn | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2020 |
| Kevin Kramer | Second-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 1995 |
| Matthew Krever | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1994 |
| Jonathan Kron | First-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 1991, 94 |
| Jonathan Kron | First-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 1994 |
| Jonathan Kron | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 1993 |
| Jason Lattimore | Second-Team Indoor | Pentathlon | 1993, 94 |
| Chris Lear | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1994 |
| Chris Lear | Second-Team Indoor | Mile | 1994 |
| Jared Lee | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2016 |
| Greg Leeper | First-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 2015 |
| Greg Leeper | First-Team Outdoor | 400 Hurdles | 2016, 2017 |
| Greg Leeper | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2014 |
| Dion Lehman | Second-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 2011 |
| Dion Lehman | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 2011 |
| Ray Lenihan | Second-Team Indoor | 60 Hurdles | 2005, 06 |
| Brian Li-A-Ping | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2007 |
| Brian Li-A-Ping | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2009 |
| Brian Li-A-Ping | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2009 |
| Brian Li-A-Ping | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2010 |
| CJ Licata | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2019, 20, 22 |
| CJ Licata | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2022 |
| Spencer Long | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 Hurdles | 2017 |
| Conor Lundy | Second-Team Indoor | 5000 | 2017 |
| Conor Lundy | Second-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 2019 |
| Conor Lundy | Second-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2019 |
| Paul Lyons | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2002, 04 |
| Paul Lyons | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2002, 03 |
| Michael Maag | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2007 |
| Michael Maag | First-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 2008 |
| Michael Maag | Second-Team Indoor | Mile | 2007 |
| Michael Maag | Second-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 2007 |
| Michael Maag | First-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 2009 |
| Michael Maag | First-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2009 |
| John Mack | First-Team Indoor | 400 | 1997, 99, 00 |
| John Mack | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1997, 99 |
| John Mack | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2000 |
| John Mack | First-Team Outdoor | 200 | 1998, 99, 00* |
| John Mack | First-Team Outdoor | 400 | 1999 |
| John Mack | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2000 |
| John Mack | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1999 |
| John Mack | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2000 |
| John Mack | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1998 |
| Frank Macreery | First-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 2006 |
| Frank Macreery | Second-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 2006 |
| Frank Macreery | First-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2006 |
| Frank Macreery | First-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 2006 |
| Frank Macreery | Second-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 2005 |
| Randy Malzbender | All-Ivy Indoor | High Jump | 1978 |
| Randy Malzbender | All-Ivy Outdoor | High Jump | 1978 |
| Gene Mancino | All-Ivy Indoor | Weight | 1976 |
| Gene Mancino | All-Ivy Outdoor | Hammer | 1976*, 77 |
| Rob Manning | Second-Team Outdoor | Javelin | 1999 |
| Rob Manning | First-Team Outdoor | Javelin | 1998 |
| Rob Manning | First-Team Outdoor | Javelin | 1997 |
| Rob Manning | Second-Team Outdoor | Javelin | 1996 |
| Craig Masback | All-Ivy Indoor | Mile | 1975, 76, 77 |
| Craig Masback | All-Ivy Indoor | 4x800 | 1977 |
| Craig Masback | All-Ivy Outdoor | 1,500 | 1976, 77 |
| Craig Masback | All-Ivy Outdoor | 880yd | 1974*, 75 |
| Nathan Mathabane | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2013 |
| Charles Matthews | First-Team Outdoor | 200 | 1989 |
| Connor Matthews | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2017 |
| Connor Matthews | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2018 |
| Mike Mazzaccaro | Second-Team Outdoor | 5k | 2015 |
| Josh McCaughey | First-Team Indoor | Weight | 2001, 02, 03, 04 |
| Josh McCaughey | First-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 2001, 02, 03, 04 |
| Garner McCloud | Second-Team Outdoor | Triple Jump | 2012 |
| Daniel McCord | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2013, 14 |
| Daniel McCord | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2013 |
| Daniel McCord | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2016 |
| Daniel McCord | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2012, 13, 14 |
| Daniel McCord | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2014 |
| Conor McCullough | First-Team Indoor | Weight | 2012 |
| Conor McCullough | First-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 2010, 12 |
| Conor McCullough | Second-Team Outdoor | Discus | 2010 |
| Matt McDonald | First-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 2015 |
| Matt McDonald | Second-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 2015 |
| Christian McFadden | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1997 |
| Joseph McGrath | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2018 |
| Kevin McGuire | First-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 1991 |
| Kevin McGuire | First-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1990, 91, 92 |
| Kevin McGuire | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1993 |
| Damon McLean | First-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 2011, 12, 13, 14 |
| Damon McLean | First-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 2013 |
| Damon McLean | Second-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 2014 |
| Damon McLean | First-Team Outdoor | Triple Jump | 2012, 13 |
| Jason Melton | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 1998, 99 |
| Ray Mennin | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2014, 2017 |
| Ray Mennin | First-Team Indoor | 400 | 2016 |
| Bob Merrilees | Second-Team Indoor | High Jump | 1983*, 84 |
| Tom Meyer | First-Team Outdoor | Javelin | 1981, 82 |
| Tom Meyer | All-Ivy Outdoor | Javelin | 1978* |
| Duncan Miller | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2022 |
| Duncan Miller | First-Team Indoor | Mile | 2023 |
| Duncan Miller | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2023 |
| Rahul Mistray | Second-Team Outdoor | 100 | 1993 |
| Manny Modu | Second-Team Indoor | 55 | 1980, 81 |
| Manny Modu | First-Team Outdoor | 100 | 1981 |
| Manny Modu | Second-Team Outdoor | 200 | 1981 |
| Rob Mohr | Second-Team Indoor | 60 Hurdles | 2013 |
| Rob Mohr | Second-Team Indoor | 60 Hurdles | 2015 |
| Steve Morgan | First-Team Indoor | 400 | 1985, 87 |
| Steve Morgan | First-Team Indoor | 55 | 1986 |
| Steve Morgan | First-Team Outdoor | 100 | 1985, 86, 87 |
| Steve Morgan | First-Team Outdoor | 200 | 1984, 85, 87 |
| Steve Morgan | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1984, 86 |
| Steve Morgan | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1984, 86 |
| Steve Morgan | Second-Team Outdoor | 100 | 1984 |
| Steve Morgan | Second-Team Outdoor | 200 | 1986 |
| Steve Morgan | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1986 |
| Paul Morrison | First-Team Indoor | Mile | 2000 |
| Paul Morrison | First-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 2000 |
| Paul Morrison | Second-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2001 |
| Paul Morrison | First-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 2000 |
| Paul Morrison | Second-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 1999* |
| Liam Morton | Second-Team Outdoor | Javelin | 2000, 01, 02 |
| Jim Murphy | Second-Team Indoor | Mile Relay | 2001 |
| Adrian Murray | Second-Team Indoor | 55 Hurdles | 1999 |
| Adrian Murray | Second-Team Outdoor | 110 Hurdles | 1998 |
| Simang'aliso Ndhlovu | Second-Team Indoor | 60 | 2019 |
| Simang'aliso Ndhlovu | First-Team Indoor | 60 | 2022 |
| Simang'aliso Ndhlovu | Second-Team Outdoor | 100 | 2022 |
| Simang'aliso Ndhlovu | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2022 |
| Justin Neidsialek | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 1999 |
| Justin Neidsialek | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1997 |
| Justin Niedzialek | First-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 1999* |
| Justin Niedzialek | Second-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 1998* |
| Dré Nelson | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2013, 14, 15 |
| David Nightingale | First-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 2006, 07 |
| David Nightingale | First-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 2007 |
| David Nightingale | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2005 |
| David Nightingale | First-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2008 |
| David Nightingale | Second-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2007 |
| Charles Norelli | All-Ivy Outdoor | Mile | 1975* |
| Charles Norelli | All-Ivy Outdoor | 1,500 | 1977 |
| Dennis Norman | First-Team Outdoor | Discus | 1999, 00 |
| Dennis Norman | Second-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 1999 |
| Steve O'Connell | All-Ivy Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 1978 |
| Brennan O'Connnor | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2018 |
| David Olds | Second-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 1983 |
| David Olds | Second-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 1982, 83 |
| Darrel Olivera | Second-Team Outdoor | Javelin | 1993 |
| Henson Orser | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1984 |
| Scott Ostrem | First-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1989 |
| Robbie Otal | Second-Team Outdoor | Discus | 2018, 2019, 22 |
| Garrett O'Toole | First-Team Indoor | Mile | 2018 |
| Garrett O'Toole | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2018 |
| Garrett O'Toole | Second-Team Indoor | Mile | 2015, 2016 |
| Garrett O'Toole | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2016, 2018 |
| Garrett O'Toole | Second-Team Outdoor | 1500 | 2018 |
| James O'Toole | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2007 |
| James O'Toole | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2008 |
| Nana Owusu-Nyantekyi | First-Team Outdoor | Triple Jump | 2015 |
| Nana Owusu-Nyantekyi | Second-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 2015 |
| John Oyler | All-Ivy Outdoor | 4x440yd | 1972 |
| Michael Palmisano | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2010 |
| Michael Palmisano | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2013 |
| Michael Palmisano | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2013 |
| Andrew Park | First-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2007 |
| Andrew Park | Second-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2005, 06 |
| Andrew Park | First-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2006 |
| Andrew Park | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2007 |
| Patrick Park | Second-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2011 |
| Patrick Park | Second-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2011 |
| William Paulson | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2018 |
| William Paulson | First-Team Outdoor | 1500 | 2018 |
| William Paulson | Second-Team Outdoor | 1500 | 2017 |
| William Paulson | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2018 |
| Craig Pearce | First-Team Indoor | Weight | 2010, 11 |
| Craig Pearce | First-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 2011 |
| Craig Pearce | Second-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 2008, 09, 10 |
| Dave Pellegrini | First-Team Indoor | Weight | 1980 |
| Alex Pessala | First-Team Indoor | Weight | 2006, 07, 09 |
| Alex Pessala | Second-Team Indoor | Weight | 2008 |
| Alex Pessala | First-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 2006, 07, 08, 09 |
| Charlie Phelps | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1996, 97, 99 |
| Charlie Phelps | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1999 |
| Michael Phillippy | Second-Team Indoor | 400 | 2020 |
| Michael Phillippy | First-Team Indoor | 400 | 2022 |
| Michael Phillippy | First-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2022 |
| Michael Phillippy | First-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2022 |
| Michael Phillippy | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2022 |
| Vermon Pierre | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1994 |
| Vermon Pierre | Second-Team Outdoor | 200 | 1995 |
| Justin Pines | Second-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 2007, 08 |
| Conrad Pitcher | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 1987 |
| Eric Plummer | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2009, 10 |
| Eric Plummer | Second-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 2008 |
| Eric Plummer | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2008, 09, 10 |
| Eric Plummer | Second-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 2007 |
| Eric Plummer | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1982 |
| Brian Poirier | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2013 |
| Austin Princewill | Second-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 2019 |
| David Pugliese | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2013 |
| Dave Pullerton | All-Ivy Indoor | Pole Vault | 1976 |
| Sean Purcell | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 1985 |
| Sean Purcell | Second-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 1986 |
| Sean Purcell | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 1985 |
| Sean Purcell | Second-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 1984 |
| Robert Quinn | Second-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 1984* |
| Robert Quinn | First-Team Outdoor | Steeplechase | 1984 |
| Martin Rawls-Meehan | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2000 |
| Justin Reed | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2004 |
| Justin Reed | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2005 |
| Justin Reed | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2004 |
| Royce Reed | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1999 |
| Royce Reed | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1997 |
| Royce Reed | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 Hurdles | 1999 |
| Royce Reed | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1999 |
| Royce Reed | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 | 1997 |
| Royce Reed | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 Hurdles | 1997 |
| Royce Reed | First-Team Outdoor | 400 | 1996 |
| Ethan Reese | Second-Team Indoor | 800 | 2022 |
| Ethan Reese | First Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2023 |
| Ethan Reese | Second Team Indoor | 800 | 2023 |
| Kaden Reynolds | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2022 |
| Phil Rice | All-Ivy Indoor | 4x800 | 1977 |
| Phil Rice | All-Ivy Indoor | 1,000yd | 1977 |
| Phil Rice | All-Ivy Outdoor | 1,500 | 1977 |
| Jay Richard | First-Team Indoor | High Jump | 1991, 92 |
| Jay Richards | First-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 1990, 92 |
| Mark Rifkin | All-Ivy Outdoor | Discus | 1980 |
| Mark Rifkin | Second-Team Outdoor | Discus | 1982 |
| Sam Rodman | First-Team Outdoor | 800 | 2022 |
| Sam Rodman | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2022 |
| Sam Rodman | First-Team Indoor | 1000 | 2023 |
| Sam Rodman | First Team-Indoor | 4x800 | 2023 |
| Brad Rowe | First-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 1980, 81, 82 |
| Brad Rowe | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1980, 81 |
| Biren Roy | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1999* |
| Lane Rusell | First-Team Outdoor | Triple Jump | 2018 |
| Chris Sallade | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1994 |
| Daniel Saltzman | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2005 |
| Daniel Saltzman | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2004 |
| Daniel Saltzman | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2004 |
| Jordan Sawadogo | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2008 |
| Jordan Sawadogo | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2011 |
| Brian Sax | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1994 |
| Fred Schnure | All-Ivy Indoor | 660yd | 1972 |
| Fred Schnure | All-Ivy Outdoor | 440yd | 1972 |
| Fred Schnure | All-Ivy Outdoor | 4x440yd | 1972 |
| Nilan Schnure | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2011 |
| Nilan Schnure | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2012 |
| Nilan Schnure | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2012 |
| Patrick Schottel | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2000 |
| Patrick Schottel | First-Team Outdoor | 200 | 2001 |
| Patrick Schottel | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2001 |
| Patrick Schottel | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2000 |
| Kurt Schulte | Second-Team Indoor | High Jump | 1981 |
| Kurt Schulte | Second-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 1981 |
| Eric Schulz | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2016 |
| Jake Scinto | Second-Team Indoor | Heptathlon | 2016 |
| Jake Scinto | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 2015 |
| Jake Scinto | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2015 |
| Tom Scott | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2013 |
| Geoff Seay | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 1984 |
| Geoff Seay | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 1984 |
| Peter Seley | First-Team Indoor | Weight | 1990 |
| Osbourne Shaw | First-Team Indoor | 400 | 1994 |
| Osbourne Shaw | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1995, 97 |
| Osbourne Shaw | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1994 |
| Michael Sherber | All-Ivy Outdoor | 400 | 1979* |
| Brian Shields | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2004 |
| Brian Shields | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2005 |
| Brian Shields | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2007 |
| Brian Shields | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2004 |
| Dan Shimooka | First-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 1998* |
| Dan Shimooka | First-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1997 |
| Greg Sholars | Second-Team Indoor | 200 | 2019 |
| Greg Sholars | Second-Team Indoor | 200 | 2020 |
| Greg Sholars | First-Team Outdoors | 4x100 | 2022 |
| Aviram Shwarzbard | Second-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 2019 |
| Aviram Shwarzbard | Second-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 2020 |
| Aviram Shwarzbard | First-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 2022 |
| Paul Simbi | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2001 |
| Paul Simbi | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2000 |
| Omar Simmons | First-Team Indoor | 500 | 1991 |
| Joe Sinisi | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1986 |
| Joe Sinisi | First-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 1986* |
| Dave Slovenski | First-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2009, 10, 11 |
| Dave Slovenski | Second-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 2012 |
| Dave Slovenski | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2011 |
| Austin Smith | First-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2005 |
| Robert Smith | Second-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 1980 |
| Stephen Soerens | First-Team Outdoor | Decathlon | 2015 |
| Ross Sullivan | First-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1985 |
| Ryan Smith | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2002 |
| Ryan Smith | First-Team Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 2001 |
| Ryan Smith | Second-Team Indoor | 800 | 2000 |
| Ryan Smith | Second-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 2002 |
| Ryan Smith | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2000 |
| Ryan Smith | First-Team Outdoor | 800 | 2002 |
| Ryan Smith | Second-Team Outdoor | 800 | 2001 |
| Ryan Smith | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2002 |
| Vince Smith | First-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 1987, 88, 90 |
| Vince Smith | First-Team Indoor | Triple Jump | 1990 |
| Vince Smith | First-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 1987, 88 |
| Vince Smith | First-Team Outdoor | 100 | 1988, 89 |
| Stephen Soerens | Second-Team Indoor | Heptathlon | 2014 |
| Stephen Soerens | Second-Team Outdoor | Decathlon | 2013, 14 |
| Kyle Soloff | Second-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 2010 |
| Kyle Soloff | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2010 |
| Kyle Soloff | Second-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2011 |
| Kyle Soloff | Second-Team Indoor | Mile | 2011 |
| Michael Spence | First-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 2000 |
| Michael Spence | Second-Team Outdoor | Steeplechase | 1999, 00 |
| Jack Stanley | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2023 |
| Sebastian Steffen | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2011 |
| Ben Stern | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2004 |
| Ben Stern | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2005 |
| Richard Stewart | First-Team Indoor | 500 | 2005, 07 |
| Richard Stewart | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2005 |
| Richard Stewart | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2004, 07 |
| Richard Stewart | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 | 2007 |
| Joe Stilin | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2011 |
| Joe Stilin | Second-Team Indoor | Mile | 2012 |
| Joe Stilin | Second-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 2012 |
| Joe Stilin | First-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 2012 |
| Kenneth Stringer | Second-Team Indoor | Weight | 2005 |
| Kenneth Stringer | Second-Team Outdoor | Hammer | 2006 |
| Adam Stuhlfaut | First-Team Indoor | 3,000 | 1998 |
| Michael Sublette | Second-Team Outdoor | 10k | 2016 |
| Michael Sullivan | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1982, 84 |
| Michael Sullivan | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 1981* |
| Michael Sullivan | Second-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 1983 |
| Ross Sullivan | First-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1985 |
| Ted Sun | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1998 |
| Joe Swenson | All-Ivy Indoor | 4x800 | 1977 |
| Joe Swenson | All-Ivy Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 1978 |
| Joe Swenson | All-Ivy Indoor | 880yd | 1978 |
| Joe Swenson | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1980 |
| Joe Swenson | Second-Team Indoor | 800 | 1980 |
| Bryant Switzer | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2014 |
| Ryan Teising | Second-Team Outdoor | 10,000 | 2001 |
| Jesse Thibodeau | Second-Team Indoor | Long Jump | 2018 |
| Jesse Thibodeau | First-Team Outdoor | Long Jump | 2019 |
| Scott Thompson | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2020 |
| Ian Thomson | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 2007, 09 |
| Ian Thomson | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2009 |
| Alex Tingan | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2003, 04 |
| Alex Tingan | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2002 |
| Ladislav Töpfer | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 2022 |
| Ladislav Töpfer | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2023 |
| Chris Totten | First-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1997 |
| Chris Totten | Second-Team Indoor | 4x400 | 1995 |
| Chris Totten | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1994 |
| Ed Trippas | First-Team Outdoor | Steeple | 2019, 22 |
| Ed Trippas | Second-Team Indoor | 5,000 | 2020 |
| Trevor Van Ackeren | First-Team Indoor | Mile | 2010 |
| Trevor Van Ackeren | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2010 |
| Trevor Van Ackeren | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 2011 |
| Trevor Van Ackeren | First-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 2012 |
| Trevor Van Ackeren | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 2012 |
| Trevor Van Ackeren | Second-Team Outdoor | 1,500 | 2012 |
| Ron Vander Kraats | All-Ivy Outdoor | 3 mile | 1973, 74 |
| Dave Van Kleeck | All-Ivy Outdoor | 4x440yd | 1972 |
| Chris Vasich | First-Team Indoor | 60 Hurdles | 2009 |
| Chris Vasich | Second-Team Outdoor | 100 Hurdles | 2009 |
| Charles Volker | First-Team Indoor | 60 | 2016 |
| Charles Volker | First-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2016, 2018 |
| Charles Volker | Second-Team Indoor | 60 | 2017 |
| Charles Volker | Second-Team Indoor | 200 | 2017 |
| Charles Volker | Second-Team Outdoor | 100 | 2017 |
| Mark Volt | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 1980, 81 |
| Mark Volt | First-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 1983 |
| Mark Volt | Second-Team Indoor | 800 | 1982 |
| Bob Ward | First-Team Indoor | Pole Vault | 1985 |
| Bob Ward | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1986 |
| John Walter | First-Team Indoor | 2 Mile Relay | 1994 |
| John Walter | Second-Team Indoor | 800 | 1994 |
| Amos Warren | First-Team Indoor | Pentathlon | 1995 |
| Amos Warren | Second-Team Indoor | Pentathlon | 1998 |
| Amos Warren | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 1998 |
| Hardy Watts | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1994 |
| Vic Waye | All-Ivy Outdoor | 440yd | 1974 |
| Austin Webb | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x100 | 2001 |
| Jeff Weicksel | All-Ivy Outdoor | 880yd | 1972 |
| Jeff Weil | All-Ivy Outdoor | 880yd | 1971 |
| Mike Weishuhn | Second-Team Indoor | High Jump | 2003 |
| Mike Weishuhn | Second-Team Outdoor | High Jump | 2005 |
| Dan Wennogle | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1995 |
| Timothy Wheeler | Second-Team Indoor | DMR | 1981* |
| Seamon Whelton | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2002 |
| Kyle Whitaker | Second-Team Outdoor | Pole Vault | 2004 |
| Steve Wilk | All-Ivy Outdoor | 220yd | 1975* |
| Michael Williams | Second-Team Outdoor | 800 | 2012 |
| Michael Williams | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2013 |
| Dan Williges | All-Ivy Indoor | Pole Vault | 1975, 76, 77 |
| Dan Williges | All-Ivy Outdoor | Pole Vault | 1974, 75, 76, 78* |
| Harrison Witt | First-Team Indoor | 1,000 | 2022 |
| Harrison Witt | Second-Team Outdoor | 4x800 | 2022 |
| John Wlader | First-Team Indoor | DMR | 1984 |
| John Wlader | First-Team Outdoor | 4x400 | 1983, 86 |
| August Wolf | First-Team Indoor | Shot Put | 1981, 82, 83 |
| August Wolf | First-Team Outdoor | Shot Put | 1981, 82, 83 |
| August Wolf | First-Team Outdoor | Discus | 1981, 82, 83 |
| Glenn Wortman | Second-Team Outdoor | 5,000 | 1981 |
| Javius Wynn | Second-Team Indoor | Pentathlon | 2001, 02, 03 |
| Tom Zozokos | Second-Team Outdoor | 400 Hurdles | 2008, 09 |
| Ed Zysik | First-Team Indoor | 4x800 | 2003 |
Note: Not all relays participants are accounted for; 1985-92 is incomplete
* = If Army/Navy finished ahead, the next highest Ivy school was named All-Ivy
Indoor
1971-78 criteria: Top 3 in each individual event and the top relay was named All-Ivy
1979 & 80 criteria: Top individual and top relay named All-Ivy
1981 the current format went into affect: Top individual and top relay is first-team All-Ivy and second-place and second relay is second-team All-Ivy.
Outdoor
1971-77 criteria: Top 3 in each individual event and the top relay was named All-Ivy
1978, 79, 80 criteria: Top individual and top relay named All-Ivy
1981 the current format went into affect: Top individual and top relay is first-team All-Ivy and second-place and second relay is second-team All-Ivy.