| 1938 |
George H. Johnson Jr. |
| 1939 |
George L. Russell III |
| 1940 |
Robert S. Ewing |
| 1941 |
John Slonaker III |
| 1942 |
Ward B. Chamerblin Jr. |
| 1943 |
N.D. Carter |
| 1944 |
--- |
| 1945 |
Moore Gates, Gerald Tompkins |
| 1946 |
Willem van Breda Kolff |
| 1947 |
Thaddeus C. Jones Jr. |
| 1948 |
Francis H. Dyckman Jr. |
| 1949 |
Francis H. Dyckman Jr. |
| 1950 |
John G. Mott |
| 1951 |
James P. Crutcher |
| 1952 |
Loyal D. Pringle |
| 1953 |
Nicholas B. Angell |
| 1954 |
Nicolas F. Cordero |
| 1955 |
James R. Monahan |
| 1956 |
Henry S. Urbaniak |
| 1957 |
Maury McKeon |
| 1958 |
E. Frederick Schrader |
| 1959 |
Thomas R. Baskett |
| 1960 |
James W. Wickenden |
| 1961 |
Lewis W. Van Amerongen |
| 1962 |
Richard W. Matlack |
| 1963 |
Gerald L. Parsky |
| 1964 |
David S. Hackett |
| 1965 |
Walter Smedley III |
| 1966 |
Peter J. Holzer |
| 1967 |
Douglas D. Ditmars |
| 1968 |
Thomas P. Weidner |
| 1969 |
Steven C. Davidson |
| 1970 |
Marshall H. Rose |
| 1971 |
Cameron O. Smith |
| 1972 |
Laszlo Adam |
| 1973 |
Dallas G. Dixon |
| 1974 |
Thomas E. Donley |
| 1975 |
Gregory Austin, Steven Tobolsky |
| 1976 |
Francis Sharry, Sergio Zeballos |
| 1977 |
Francis Sharry |
| 1978 |
Douglas F. Colson |
| 1979 |
Mark A. Mulert |
| 1980 |
Charles V. Stillitano |
| 1981 |
John G. Bowen |
| 1982 |
John F. Mohrmann |
| 1983 |
Thomas I. Poz, Roy A. Stanley |
| 1984 |
Yuri Fishman, Richard Kraemer |
| 1985 |
Steven C. Milke, Joseph N. Walsh |
| 1986 |
Michael Attansio, Sean Kavanagh |
| 1987 |
Will Doniger, David Vaudreuil |
| 1988 |
Christpher Ruder, Karl Schellscheidt |
| 1989 |
Christopher Ruder, Karl Schellscheidt |
| 1990 |
Jim Barlow, Tom McCabe, Pat White |
| 1991 |
Matthew L. Reece |
| 1992 |
D. Shawn Pierson |
| 1993 |
Joseph P. Thieman |
| 1994 |
Thaddeus R. McBride |
| 1995 |
Andrew Lewis, Jesse Marsch |
| 1996 |
Jeffrey Plunkett |
| 1997 |
Jamie Adams, Krysztof Halupka |
| 1998 |
Chad Adams, Krysztof Halupka |
| 1999 |
Chad C. Adams |
| 2000 |
Kevin Griffin, Graeme Rein |
| 2001 |
Matt Behncke, Bob Nye, Graeme Rein |
| 2002 |
Bob Nye, Jason White, Jeff Hare |
| 2003 |
Gianfranco Tripicchio, Jeff Hare |
| 2004 |
Teddy van Beuren |
| 2005 |
Adrian Melville, Darren Spicer |
| 2006 |
Jame Wunsch |
| 2007 |
Matt Kontos, Kyle McHugh |
| 2008 |
Devin Muntz, Matt Care |
| 2009 |
Devin Muntz |
| 2010 |
Sean Lynch |
| 2011 |
Mark Linville |
| 2012 |
Mark Linville, Matt Sanner |
| 2013 |
Billy McGuinness, Patrick O'Neil |
| 2014 |
Myles McGinley, Andrew Mills, Josh Miller |
| 2015 |
Brendan McSherry, Josh Miller |
| 2016 |
Patrick Barba |
| 2017 |
Matthew Mangini, James Reiner |
| 2018 |
Sean McSherry, Jacob Schachner |
| 2019 |
Danny Hampton, Jacob Schachner |
| 2020 |
N/A |
| 2021 |
Alex Charles, Kevin O'Toole, Jack Roberts |
| 2022 |
Lucas Gen |
| 2023 |
Francis Akomeah, Ryan Winkler |
| 2024 |
Issa Mudashiru, Khamari Hadaway, Harry Roberts |
