| USILA Awards |
|
| W. Wilson Wingate Award |
| Men’s National Champion • Division I |
| Princeton (10): 1937, 1942, 1951, 1953, 1992, 1994, 1996, 1997, 1998, 2001 |
|
|
| F. Morris Touchstone Award |
| Coach of the Year – Division I |
| 1967 |
Ferris Thomsen |
| 1992 |
Bill Tierney |
|
|
| Lt. Raymond J. Enners Award |
| Outstanding Player – Division I |
| 1993 |
David Morrow |
| 1994 |
Scott Bacigalupo |
|
|
| Lt. Col. J.L. (Jack) Turnbull Award |
| Outstanding Attackman – Division I |
| 1951 |
Donald Hahn |
| 1994 |
Kevin Lowe |
| 1997 |
Jon Hess |
|
|
| Ensign C. Markland Kelly Jr. Award |
| Outstanding Goaltender – Division I |
| 1992 |
Scott Bacigalupo |
| 1993 |
Scott Bacigalupo |
| 1994 |
Scott Bacigalupo |
| 2001 |
Trevor Tierney |
| 2006 |
Alex Hewit |
|
|
| Lt. j.g. Donald MacLaughlin Jr. Award |
| Outstanding Midfielder – Division I |
| 1998 |
Josh Sims |
| 2000 |
Josh Sims |
| 2013 |
Tom Schreiber |
| 2014 |
Tom Schreiber |
|
|
| William C. Schmeisser Award |
| Outstanding Defenseman – |
| Division I |
|
| 1942 |
Tyler Campbell |
| 1947 |
Frederick Allner |
| 1992 |
David Morrow |
| 1993 |
David Morrow |
| 1998 |
Christian Cook |
| 2001 |
Ryan Mollett |
|
|
| The Howdy Myers Man of the Year Award |
| 1948 |
Conrad Sutherland |
| 1959 |
Ferris Thomsen |
| 1983 |
Howard Krongard |
|
|
| Doyle Smith Media Award |
| 2010 |
Jerry Price |
|
|
| W.H. Brine Trophy |
| Most Valuable Player |
| Division I Championship |
| 1992 |
Scott Bacigalupo |
| 1994 |
Scott Bacigalupo |
| 1997 |
Jon Hess |
| 1998 |
Corey Popham |
| 2001 |
B.J. Prager |
|
|
| USILA Scholar All-Americas |
| 1990 |
Tom Barnds |
| 1992 |
Justin Tortolani |
|
Greg Waller |
| 1994 |
Scott Bacigalupo |
|
Peter Ramsey |
|
Scott Reinhardt |
|
Taylor Simmers |
| 1995 |
Nick Lane |
| 2000 |
Josh Sims |
|
Chris Berrier |
| 2001 |
Ryan Mollett |
|
Trevor Tierney |
|
Matt Striebel |
| 2002 |
Scott Farrell |
|
B.J. Prager |
| 2003 |
Brian Lieberman |
| 2004 |
Ryan Boyle |
|
Drew Casino |
|
Ricky Schultz |
| 2005 |
Oliver Barry |
|
Jason Doneger |
| 2006 |
Zachary Jungers |
|
Scott Sowanick |
| 2014 |
Jack Strabo |
| 2015 |
Austin deButts |
