| Year |
Captains |
| 1996Â |
John L Haller |
| 1997 |
Luis Alvarez |
| 1998 |
Oakley A. Brooks |
| 1999 |
Gregory S. Stoll |
| 2000 |
Chris Gratian, James Orozco |
| 2001 |
Jonathan M. Pharis, Marshall D. Roslyn |
| 2002 |
Kevin Foster, Rob Urquhart |
| 2003 |
D.J. Halliday, Daniel McKenna |
| 2004 |
Michael Murray, Peter Sabbatini |
| 2005 |
Jamal Motlagh, John Stover |
| 2006 |
Reid Joseph, Chris Kelsch, Nicholas Seaver |
| 2007 |
Zack Beckmann, Scott Syverson |
| 2008 |
Brendan Colgan, Alex Edmunds |
| 2009 |
Gregor Horstmeyer, Eric Vreeland, Douglas Wigley |
| 2010 |
Matt Hale, Mike Merlone |
| 2011 |
Jeff Cole, Mike Helou |
| 2012 |
Jack Ruth, Billy Tifft |
| 2013 |
Kurt Buchbinder, Drew Hoffenberg |
| 2014 |
Kayj Shannon, Drew Hoffenberg |
| 2015 |
Jamie Kuprenas, Thomas Nelson |
| 2016 |
Jovan Jeremic, Curtis Fink |
| 2017 |
Vojislav Mitrovic, Jordan Colina, Eric Bowen, Ryan Hammarsjkold |
| 2018 |
Ryan Melosini, Ryan Wilson, Michael Swart, Matt Payne, P.J. Greenbaum, Oliver Schmickel |
| 2019 |
Casey Conrad, Logan MacDonell, Sean Duncan, Davis Wachtell |
| 2021 |
Wyatt Benson, Billy Motherway, Mitchell Cooper |
| 2022 |
Keller Maloney, Ryan Neapole, Yurian Quinones, Antonio Knez |
| 2023 |
Isaac Rotenberg, Yurian Quinones, Pierce Maloney, Alex Roose |
