| Year |
Captains |
| 1872 |
H.B. Burt |
| 1873 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1874 |
W.M. Smith |
| 1875 |
B. Nicoll |
| 1876 |
B. Nicoll |
| 1877 |
B. Nicoll |
| 1878 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1879 |
A. McLaren |
| 1880 |
A. McLaren |
| 1881 |
J.T. Cowan |
| 1882 |
G.B. Jennison |
| 1883 |
G.B. Jennison |
| 1884 |
C.W. Bird |
| 1885 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1886 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1887 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1888 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1889 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1890 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1891 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1892 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1893 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1894 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1895 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1896 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1897 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1898 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1899 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1900 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1901 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1902 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1903 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1904 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1905 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1906 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1907 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1908 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1909 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1910 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1911 |
R.T. Roche |
| 1912 |
Rudolph S. Rauch |
| 1913 |
Rudolph S. Rauch |
| 1914 |
Theodore C. Briggs |
| 1915 |
Olin S. Putnam |
| 1916 |
Robert A. Cochran III |
| 1917 |
Robert A. Cochran III/Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1918 |
Harding S. Roche |
| 1919 |
William M. Paxton III |
| 1920 |
R.S. Lamont |
| 1921 |
Hugh. C. Cresswell |
| 1922 |
Sidney W. Milne |
| 1923 |
John T. Pirie II |
| 1924 |
John T. Pirie II |
| 1925 |
Walter G. Dyer |
| 1926 |
Arthur Kennedy, Jr. |
| 1927 |
H. Clark |
| 1928 |
Herbert R. Stratford |
| 1929 |
James Macn Thompson |
| 1930 |
James O. Pease |
| 1931 |
Robert L. Colmore |
| 1932 |
J.G. Shennan |
| 1933 |
B.W. Smith |
| 1934 |
Aikman Armstrong |
| 1935 |
Gordon Keppel |
| 1936 |
Gordon Keppel |
| 1937 |
Harlan J. Swift |
| 1938 |
Philip Le Boutillier, Jr. |
| 1939 |
Jack W. Pitney |
| 1940 |
Alexis I. DuP. Bayard |
| 1941 |
Evan W. Thomas II |
| 1942 |
Herbert E. Jones, Jr. |
| 1943 |
Lon F. Israel |
| 1944 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1945 |
Varsity crew competition suspended |
| 1946 |
Rex Peters |
| 1947 |
Laird U. Park, Jr. |
| 1948 |
Herbert L. Dillon, Jr. |
| 1949 |
Peter V.W. Gardner |
| 1950 |
Robert B. O'Connor, Jr. |
| 1951 |
Thomas M. Marshall |
| 1952 |
Edgar M. Masinter |
| 1953 |
John C. Beck, Samuel L. Ertell |
| 1954 |
John Jay Humphrey |
| 1955 |
Hamilton Robinson, Jr. |
| 1956 |
Robert Haskelkorn |
| 1957 |
Stephen B. Strang, Jr. |
| 1958 |
Neil D. Chrisman |
| 1959 |
Edward A. Lasater |
| 1960 |
Robert D. Bach |
| 1961 |
Douglas R. Henley |
| 1962 |
Andrew D. Hall, Guy G. Rutherford, Jr. |
| 1963 |
Anthony A. Jones |
| 1964 |
Findley Meislahn |
| 1965 |
Michael P. Clifford |
| 1966 |
Lynn R. Anderson |
| 1967 |
James R. Millar |
| 1968 |
Peter H. Raymond |
| 1969 |
Raymond G. Wright |
| 1970 |
Lauren K. Colman |
| 1971 |
Ronald J. Brachman |
| 1972 |
James R. Paulson |
| 1973 |
Daniel A. Hudacek |
| 1974 |
Stephen F. Deutsch, Philip D. Lyman |
| 1975 |
Christopher W. Dietemann |
| 1976 |
Lawrence A. Smith |
| 1977 |
Lawrence A. Smith |
| 1978 |
Scot A. Fisher |
| 1979 |
Christian T. Dembergh |
| 1980 |
Samuel P. Whalen |
| 1981 |
David M. Mastrianni |
| 1982 |
Philip M. Jacobs, David S. Kuhl |
| 1983 |
Eric L. Horschman |
| 1984 |
Mark Wilson |
| 1985 |
John C. Feudtner |
| 1986 |
Timothy W. Van Leer |
| 1987 |
William N. Sheehan |
| 1988 |
Douglas W. Burden |
| 1989 |
Paul J. Caminiti, David S. Huntington |
| 1990 |
Joseph P. Caminiti, Andrew D. Morrow |
| 1991 |
Eric K. Karplus |
| 1992 |
Bradley W. Mann |
| 1993 |
Thomas W. Brennan |
| 1994 |
Stephen D. Robinson |
| 1995 |
Kevin T. Hipp |
| 1996 |
Matthew J. Rutherford |
| 1997 |
Tedmont K. Carson |
| 1998 |
Christopher W. Bordeau |
| 1999 |
Geoff Adamson |
| 2000 |
David Bordeau |
| 2001 |
Mark Flickinger |
| 2002 |
Sean McCormick |
| 2003 |
J.P. Cranston |
| 2004 |
Spencer Washburn |
| 2005 |
Spencer Washburn |
| 2006 |
Steve Coppola |
| 2007 |
Will England |
| 2008 |
Glenn Ochal |
| 2009 |
Matthew Evans |
| 2010 |
Michael Gilson |
| 2011 |
Jack Lindeman |
| 2012 |
Ian Silveira |
| 2013 |
Michael Evans |
| 2014 |
Will Gillis |
| 2015 |
James Hamp |
| 2016 |
Martin Barakso |
| 2017 |
Nick Mead |
| 2018 |
Augustin Wambersie |
| 2019 |
Andrew Morgan |
| 2020 |
David Bewicke-Copley |
| 2021 |
Tassilo von Mueller |
| 2022 |
Jonas Juel |
| 2023 |
Jelmer Bennema |
| 2024 |
Marco Van Blarcum De Graaff Misasi |
| 2025 |
Nicholas A. Rath |
