| Year |
Captains |
| 1920 |
N/A |
| 1921 |
N/A |
| 1922 |
J.T. Witherspoon |
| 1923 |
R.O. Reed |
| 1924 |
Matthew Baird III |
| 1925 |
John J. Livingood |
| 1926 |
C.H. Cromwell, Jr. |
| 1927 |
W.B. Krag |
| 1928 |
J.H. Thompson |
| 1929 |
I. Kerr |
| 1930 |
T. Felton Wimberly, Jr. |
| 1931 |
Lucius F. Hallett, Jr., Charles T.H. Moore |
| 1932 |
N/A |
| 1933 |
Standish Backus, Jr. |
| 1934 |
Henry C. Mial |
| 1935 |
Durand Echeverria |
| 1936 |
G.R. Cooke |
| 1937 |
Beverly W. Warner |
| 1938 |
John F. Kraemer |
| 1939 |
Eben C. Hall |
| 1940 |
Philip O. Stearns |
| 1941 |
Peter M. Dean |
| 1942 |
Eugene W. (Butch) Mason, Jr. |
| 1943 |
N/A |
| 1944 |
Lightweight crew competition suspended |
| 1945 |
Lightweight crew competition suspended |
| 1946 |
John S. Ralston, Jr. |
| 1947 |
James H. Stewart, Jr. |
| 1948 |
Jack P. Eiler |
| 1949 |
Michael W. Huber |
| 1950 |
Henry L. Bird |
| 1951 |
Gerald M. Mayer |
| 1952 |
William C. Kappes, Jr. |
| 1953 |
Jay W. Jacobs |
| 1954 |
David G. Powell |
| 1955 |
Thomas C.H. Webster |
| 1956 |
William W. Statterfield |
| 1957 |
James R. Newcomer |
| 1958 |
Charles L. Moran III |
| 1959 |
Michael J. Kelly |
| 1960 |
Oscar B. Marx III |
| 1961 |
Albert MacKenzie |
| 1962 |
Douglas H. Latimer |
| 1963 |
Frederick G. Brown |
| 1964 |
James B. Street |
| 1965 |
Jeffrey R. Fisher |
| 1966 |
Robert B. McGinley |
| 1967 |
Richard O. Prentke |
| 1968 |
John P. Doran |
| 1969 |
J. Stephen Deupree |
| 1970 |
John S. Slete |
| 1971 |
Edwin C. Yeary, Jr. |
| 1972 |
Jesse T. Davidson III, John J. Griffin |
| 1973 |
Arthur G. Oller |
| 1974 |
William M. Walton III |
| 1975 |
William A. Hayne |
| 1976 |
Wendell B. Colson |
| 1977 |
Jonathan H. Jaffin, Gary J. Moffat |
| 1978 |
Jacob H. Gregory, Robert F. Werner |
| 1979 |
Jacob H. Gregory |
| 1980 |
Christopher R. Gaylord, Robert Sommer |
| 1981 |
William B. Doyle, Jr., Stephen W. Morss |
| 1982 |
Robert B. Van Cleve II |
| 1983 |
John S. Andrews |
| 1984 |
Mark G. Califano |
| 1985 |
Andrew L. Card, Michael W. Wais |
| 1986 |
Robert G. Hedlund III, Jesse E. Smedley |
| 1987 |
Andrew S. Ballard |
| 1988 |
Michael K. Atalay |
| 1989 |
Jon D. Sarnoff, Robert Q. Scacheri |
| 1990 |
Michael G. Anderer, Michael G. Hirschfeld |
| 1991 |
Matthew R. Camuso, Jasper A. Malcolmson |
| 1992 |
Stephen M. Hope |
| 1993 |
Samuel S. McMillan IV |
| 1994 |
Graham C. Weaver |
| 1995 |
Alexander R. Horner, Christian M. Pettker |
| 1996 |
David M. Lawson, Gregory C. Hughes |
| 1997 |
Tomas V. Fernandez, Alfredo Cabeza |
| 1998 |
Simon G. Carcagno, Robert H. Milam |
| 1999 |
Jon Lawson |
| 2000 |
Joseph Dinorcia, William E. Fedyna |
| 2001 |
Jim Johannes, Jeremy Sellars |
| 2002 |
Bill Foshay, Brian Romanzo |
| 2003 |
J.T. Mannion |
| 2004 |
J.F. Wachter, J.P. Ference |
| 2005 |
A.W. Swanson, M.S. Collinson |
| 2006 |
Prentice Stabler |
| 2007 |
Greg McKallagat |
| 2008 |
Taylor Washburn |
| 2009 |
Tom Paulett, Justin Teti |
| 2010 |
Jack Leonard |
| 2011 |
Robin Prendes |
| 2012 |
Gianthomas Volpe |
| 2013 |
Tyler Nase |
| 2014 |
Scotty Tinsman |
| 2015 |
Casey Ward |
| 2016 |
Isiah Brown |
| 2017 |
Forrest Daugherty |
| 2018 |
Patrick Watt |
| 2019 |
Danny Hogan |
| 2020 |
Theo Long, Adam Teece |
| 2021 |
Marcus Jonas, David Slear |
| 2022 |
Andrew Berg, Henry Vecchione |
| 2023 |
George Dickinson, Will Olson |
| 2024 |
Paul Hoeselbarth, Eoin Gaffney |
| 2025 |
Nick Aronow, Will Nash |
